Updated
subscribers. Become an Insider
and start reading now.
Have an account? .
- It’s a time-honored TV tradition that the best characters are usually side characters.
- That leaves some main characters that are far less popular.
- Dan Humphrey, Emily Cooper, and Will Schuester are some of TV’s most annoying characters — sorry.
Often, a TV show’s main character is its moral compass, but that’s no fun to watch, so they are also typically messy and mistake-prone … which means they’re also hypocrites.
At least that’s the case for many of these characters, which we’ve deemed to be the most annoying main characters in TV history.
Meanwhile, anti-heroes and snarky side characters can be morally gray, get all the good one-liners, and make the difficult decisions the heroes can’t.
The following TV shows all lasted for many seasons, leading to successful and lucrative careers for their stars. However, the actors may never be able to fully escape how much they annoyed some viewers.
Here are some of the most annoying main characters in TV history.
Ted Moseby from “How I Met You Mother”
Even though Ted’s annoying qualities were built into his character — and in fact, his friends were constantly making fun of his quirks — it didn’t mean it was any easier to watch him constantly make horrible decisions in his love life.
Over the course of nine seasons, we watched Ted emotionally terrorize multiple women, secretly pine for his best friend’s fiancée, help another woman leave her husband-to-be at the altar, and then wonder why he wasn’t finding his happily ever after.
Besides that, Ted is a snob, a stickler for grammar, and just a judgmental person. We think “HIMYM” should’ve just been about Marshall.
Elena Gilbert from “The Vampire Diaries”
Elena Gilbert ping-ponged between two brothers on “The Vampire Diaries,” making her no better than her doppelgänger, Katherine.
When Elena meets Stefan and Damon, a pair of vampire brothers, in the first couple of episodes of “The Vampire Diaries,” she learns about their shared ex-girlfriend, Katherine. She also learns that Katherine’s manipulations of the brothers led to a century-long rift between them.
Katherine is also established as one of the show’s most formidable antagonists, with almost all of the characters hating her and judging her — and she admits to being a villain.
But what did Elena do over the course of the first six seasons of “TVD”? She started by dating Stefan while developing feelings for Damon, and she eventually dumped Stefan to be with Damon.
That’s not even the annoying part, though.
What actually gets us is that Elena is probably one of the most self-righteous main characters in TV history, judging everyone else for making mistakes. Meanwhile, the character whose actions she most closely emulates is Katherine. Make it make sense!
Lucas Scott from “One Tree Hill”
Lucas pitted two best friends against each other on “One Tree Hill” in a toxic love triangle.
Some advice: If a boy is dating your best friend while simultaneously sharing some of his deepest darkest secrets with you, bonding with you over your shared love of music and art, and brooding about your friendship … run.
We wish we could have told Brooke and Peyton this before they jeopardized their lifelong friendship for the affections of Lucas Scott in the first six seasons of “OTH.”
Honestly, Lucas earned a spot on “FBoy Island” with the way he treated women.
Ross Geller from “Friends”
Ross Geller made us laugh, sure, but he also made us groan on “Friends.”
If all you have to say in response to sleeping with someone else the night you break up with your girlfriend is, “We were on a break,” you’re annoying. Those are just the rules.
Ross easily provided some of the funniest moments throughout the 10 seasons of “Friends,” and we’d never get rid of him. But his pretentiousness, “nice guy” vibes, and how he felt entitled to Rachel even after they had broken up remain annoying.
Rory Gilmore from “Gilmore Girls”
Rory’s lack of growth on “Gilmore Girls” annoyed fans to no end, and her downfall in the Netflix revival of “Gilmore Girls” was the main topic of discussion after the show premiered in 2016, nine years after the original show ended.
She still acted like a teenager, was sleeping with an engaged man, and kept forgetting to break up with her perfectly nice boyfriend.
But real fans know that Rory has always been annoying. Who can forget when she called her ex-boyfriend Dean “my Dean,” even though he was married to someone else?
Or when she decided to drop out of Yale and steal a boat and then had the gall to act annoyed when she got sentenced to community service instead of prison?
Or when she got mad at one of her fellow students for stealing her study spot under a tree at Yale?
The list goes on and on. It’s not like Lorelai or Emily are perfect, but we’d much prefer a Rory-lite seven seasons of “Gilmore Girls.”
Dan Humphrey from “Gossip Girl”
The finale reveal that Dan was Gossip Girl made him extremely creepy. But before he was creepy, he was just a grating presence on the Upper East Side.
Dan simultaneously hated his upper-crust classmates and was desperate to be one of them. Even though he vocally complained about them, Dan ended up dating Blair and Serena and befriending Nate, three of the wealthiest people at his high school.
Plus, his Williamsburg loft was easily worth at least $1 million, and his dad was a former rock star turned gallery owner. You are not poor, Dan!
Carrie Bradshaw from “Sex and the City”
There’s no shortage of memes about how annoying Carrie Bradshaw is.
Once “SATC” was revived as “And Just Like That,” the memes started coming, and they haven’t stopped. An all-time meme format is how each one of the ladies would respond to various situations or disasters — and without fail, Carrie’s only response is “Big is moving to Paris.”
Across “SATC’s” six seasons, Carrie proved to be a bad friend, self-involved, a cheater, and sometimes delusional.
However, she holds the friend group together and remains iconic, so we’ll take her, annoying tendencies and all.
Will Schuester from “Glee”
When Mr. Schue pops up on TikTok, he comes with a trigger warning. Really. Anytime a “Glee” performance or scene is posted online, the caption or comments warn that the Glee Club’s faculty advisor will appear.
Between his inappropriate performances with his students, his punishing of Marley for not wanting to wear a bikini during a school performance, his dedication to rapping or singing ’80s rock, and his declaration that all the kids in New Directions were “minorities” because they were in glee club, we can’t pick the most annoying thing about Will.
Debbie Gallagher from “Shameless”
By design, the Gallagher family is full of anti-heroes. But over the course of 11 seasons, one Gallagher comes to mind as the most annoying, and that’s Debbie.
Where to start? Most infamously, Debbie traps her boyfriend into getting her pregnant and then feels entitled to her older sister Fiona’s support, even though Fiona made it clear she didn’t approve of Debbie keeping the baby.
But Debbie never seemed to learn from her mistakes, and she didn’t have the charm that Fiona, Lip, Ian, or even Carl did. Unfortunately, that lands her at the bottom of our Gallagher rankings.
Dawson Leery from “Dawson’s Creek”
Even though it was “Dawson’s Creek,” we’d prefer to leave Dawson out of it and focus on Joey, Pacey, and Jen.
If you’ve seen just one episode of “Dawson’s Creek,” you’ll know why people can’t stand Dawson. He strung his best friend Joey along for years, resented when she found happiness with Pacey, couldn’t process any of his feelings outside movie references, and had one of the worst crying faces of all time.
It’s a wonder that “Dawson’s Creek” lasted six seasons without Dawson getting yelled at constantly.
Emily Cooper from “Emily in Paris”
It is not hyperbole to say that the most ludicrous show on Netflix (and perhaps all of television) is “Emily in Paris.”
And while we love some of the improbability (the unbelievable fashion, Ashley Park’s performance as Mindy, how iconically rude Sylvie is), there is one thing that we’ll never get over: how annoying Emily is to watch.
Emily has never made a good decision in her life. She constantly emotionally cheats on every partner with her neighbor Gabriel, but refused to date him for multiple seasons due to “girl code” … even though Gabriel’s ex Camille is a horrible friend to Emily (don’t get us started on her villainy).
She never listens to her boss or coworkers, but somehow continues to fail upward. Also, every man she encounters immediately falls in love with her.
Will we tune into season five, though? Duh.