Epistemological insecurity, a condition denoting the widespread uncertainty regarding the construction of objective social truth, has profoundly influenced democratic participation in Pakistan. Misinformation, deliberate distortions of reality, and manipulating narratives discourage civic engagement, weaken institutions, and create a fragmented society. This phenomenon is not exclusive to Pakistan; similar trends have been observed worldwide, where disinformation has reshaped democratic participation, eroded trust in governance, and altered the nature of political discourse.
In Pakistan, a key manifestation of epistemological insecurity is the growing public disillusionment with democratic institutions during elections and broader governance issues. The spread of misinformation through social media platforms, private messaging apps, and unregulated online sources has led many citizens to question the legitimacy of parliament, the judiciary, and regulatory authorities. False narratives regarding corruption, policy failures, and economic mismanagement circulate widely, often undermining genuine reform efforts. This has contributed to a dangerous cycle where citizens disengage from political processes, believing their participation will have no tangible impact on governance.
This erosion of trust is evident in various spheres of governance. For instance, economic policy misinformation has directly impacted public sentiment and financial behaviour. In early 2023, false reports of an imminent economic collapse led to panic buying and capital flight, exacerbating an already fragile economic situation. Similar trends have been observed globally. In Argentina, disinformation regarding inflation policies and debt restructuring contributed to losing investor confidence, worsening the financial crisis. In the UK, misleading claims about Brexit’s economic consequences fueled public uncertainty, affecting business decisions and long-term economic planning.
Beyond economic policies, misinformation has influenced public responses to health crises. During the COVID-19 pandemic, Pakistan faced widespread vaccine skepticism due to fabricated reports suggesting harmful side effects, government conspiracies, and foreign agendas. This led to lower vaccination rates in certain regions, complicating public health efforts. A parallel example can be found in the United States, where anti-vaccine misinformation became a deeply polarizing issue, reducing vaccine uptake among specific political demographics and undermining efforts to contain the virus.
Globally, epistemological insecurity has also fueled social unrest and political instability. The January 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol was driven by conspiracy theories and misinformation about election fraud, highlighting how disinformation can lead to direct threats against democratic institutions. Similarly, in Brazil, supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro stormed government buildings in 2023 after being misled into believing the election results were rigged. In Pakistan, misinformation has been a significant factor in protests and political unrest, with rival political groups using digital platforms to amplify unverified claims, sometimes resulting in violent confrontations.
Religious and ideological misinformation also plays a role in discouraging civic engagement. In Pakistan, the weaponization of religious rhetoric has been used to delegitimize political opponents and incite public outrage. Social media platforms have been flooded with misleading claims accusing politicians, activists, and reformists of blasphemy or working against national interests. This has resulted in self-censorship, as individuals fear backlash for engaging in public discussions on sensitive political issues. Similar strategies have been observed in India, where political actors have used misinformation to stoke communal tensions and marginalize dissenting voices.
Education and intellectual discourse have also been affected. In many parts of the world, including Pakistan, the spread of misinformation has created an environment where academic expertise is often dismissed in favour of politically convenient narratives. The rejection of expert opinions on climate change, public health, and economic policies has weakened the role of academia in shaping national policies. In the United States, climate change denial, fueled by misinformation campaigns, has delayed meaningful legislative action. In Pakistan, misleading economic narratives have led to widespread public misconceptions about debt management, IMF negotiations, and fiscal policies, making it harder for governments to implement necessary reforms.
Efforts to combat epistemological insecurity require a multi-pronged approach. Governments must enhance transparency in decision-making, ensuring that accurate and verifiable information is readily available to the public. Fact-checking organizations and media outlets must take a proactive role in countering misinformation. Additionally, digital literacy programs should be expanded to educate citizens on identifying false narratives and critically analyzing information sources. Countries like Finland have successfully implemented digital literacy initiatives in school curriculums to inoculate their citizens against misinformation; Pakistan could benefit from adopting similar strategies.
The future of democracy in Pakistan and globally depends on restoring trust in institutions, promoting accurate information, and encouraging informed civic engagement. Without addressing epistemological insecurity, political participation will continue to decline, leaving governance increasingly susceptible to manipulation by misinformation campaigns. By prioritizing truth, education, and institutional integrity, Pakistan can strengthen its democratic foundations and ensure citizens are empowered to make decisions based on facts rather than fabricated narratives.
[Image by memyselfaneye from Pixabay]
Qasim Ali Shah is a former faculty member at the National University of Sciences and Technology (NUST) and holds a PhD in Development Studies from COMSATS University Islamabad. The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author.
Read the full article here
