- US troops remain in Syria to counter ISIS and patrol oil fields in the region.
- Trump’s return raises uncertainties about the status of these troops in this highly volatile region.
- Both Turkey and the Kurdish-led officials hope to sway the incoming Trump administration.
For almost a decade, US troops have been on the ground in Syria to assist Kurdish-led forces in the defeat of the infamous Islamic State. These forces tamp down on the ISIS remnants in the northern and eastern regions they presently control, where tens of thousands of captured ISIS fighters, their families and suspected affiliates remain in open-air camps and prisons.
But there’s a new wrinkle of uncertainty in this highly volatile and contested region: US President-elect Donald Trump.
During his first term, Trump ordered the withdrawal of US troops partnered with the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces after ISIS’ territorial defeat. Trump did this following a phone call with the president of Turkey, a staunch rival of the SDF, resulting in an immediate cross-border Turkish operation against those US-allied forces. Trump then backtracked and kept 900 US troops in Syria.
His imminent return to the Oval Office once again raises the specter that the US could pull out, leaving a power vacuum that Turkey, the Syrian regime, and Russia may move to fill at the SDF’s expense. The resulting instability could be an opening for ISIS to regroup. Turkish officials want the US to leave, with the incumbent defense minister stating, “Trump will strongly focus on this.” But the Kurds hope they can persuade him otherwise.
“We formed a successful alliance with the United States in combating terrorism,” Sinam Mohamad, the representative of the Syrian Democratic Council mission to the United States and a top diplomat of the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria, told Business Insider.
“We may have felt frustrated during Trump’s first term due to his decision to withdraw American forces from Syria in 2019,” Mohamad said. “But today, as a result of the political circumstances in the Middle East and the world, we see that President Trump will have a different outlook than before.”
The AANES administrates large swathes of north and east Syria under the SDF’s control.
The regime of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad, which is backed by Russia, does not recognize the AANES. Turkey vehemently opposes it, claiming the SDF has inextricable ties to its main adversary, the Kurdistan Workers’ Party, or PKK. Turkish strikes against AANES infrastructure have cut off water and electricity to over a million people, leading to charges that Turkey is violating international law.
“The incoming Trump administration has an opportunity to reconfigure the entire US strategy in Syria, maintain its minimal but high-rewards troops presence in Syria, and proceed with a bold vision to mend fences between Syrian Kurds and Ankara,” Mohammed A. Salih, a non-resident senior fellow in the Foreign Policy Research Institute and an expert on Kurdish and regional affairs, told BI.
“The focus should be on a win-win outcome for all sides, America, Kurds, and Turkey.”
Some called for a US withdrawal after the January drone attack against a US base in Jordan that supports operations in Syria, killing three Americans and injuring 47.
The specific timing of any American withdrawal will also be a critical factor.
“The American withdrawal from Syria may take place in 2026 or before that, but what will be different are the circumstances that will accompany this withdrawal,” the SDC’s Mohamad said. “It may take into account the dangers facing the areas of the autonomous administration and Washington’s allies in the fight against terrorism, and at that time, it is necessary to ensure the withdrawal with political security for the region.”
The official underlined the continued importance of the American presence for ensuring “the continuation of the fight against terrorism” and that the SDF can continue securing the “large number of prisoners of the terrorist organizations languishing” in AANES detention.
The Kurds have thousands of former ISIS fighters in its camps and detention centers. The sprawling Al-Hol camp has a population of over 40,000, including thousands of ISIS women and children, a number of whom remain radicalized. It has warned that another Turkish invasion would divert SDF fighters and resources away from securing these facilities.
“The Syrian Democratic Forces have the qualifications to secure these facilities,” said Mohamad, the Kurdish diplomat. “But they will not be able to perform their duty to the fullest extent if the withdrawal occurs without political security for the region’s situation.”
Mohamad stressed that AANES and SDF would want American guarantees that Turkey will not invade after a US withdrawal.
“A sudden troop withdrawal could probably result in even more disastrous outcomes than in Afghanistan, given the presence of various regional and global powers in Syria and the resurgence of ISIS and other jihadi groups there,” said Salih, the FPRI regional expert.
“In all likelihood, the situation will be highly chaotic in the event of a withdrawal with serious consequences that could witness the mass escaping of ISIS prisoners, likely more radicalized and resentful as a result of their prison experience,” Salih added.
While weakened from years of war, ISIS has already demonstrated its capability to regroup and threaten their adversaries. A coordinated ISIS jailbreak attempt in 2022 led to almost two weeks of heavy fighting with the SDF.
A rapid US withdrawal tips the uneasy balance of powers. Salih anticipates this could lead to “a hectic race” between Iran, Russia, the Syrian regime, and Turkey for the resource-rich AANES regions.
“All the problems we suffer from in the regions of North and East Syria are related to the necessity of placing our region within the international solution platforms related to Syria, political support, and finding a solution to the Syrian crisis with the participation of the Autonomous Administration and the Syrian Democratic Council in the political process,” Mohamad said.
“This will have a major impact in changing the shape of the region, reducing hotbeds of tension, and ensuring global security and peace.”
Paul Iddon is a freelance journalist and columnist who writes about Middle East developments, military affairs, politics, and history. His articles have appeared in a variety of publications focused on the region.
